Although our families have spread to the four corners of this country in the nearly 140 years documented here, their beginnings center on three primary regions in the northeast. Rosendale, in Ulster County New York, the County of Kings (Brooklyn) which is part of the five boroughs of New York City, and Quincy in Essex County, Massachusetts. Places of Interest will attempt to document the places where they lived, worked and worshiped. I paid particular interest to the church they attended because much of what I have been able to reconstruct over the years has been through baptismal and marital records. Their godparents were usually family members or close friends who figured largely in their network of countrymen. Our experience in the New World begins with a young rebel on the run from the British after a failed uprising in Tipperary Ireland in 1866.
James Fleming was born in Carrickbeg, County Waterford, Ireland in 28 February,1846 the third child of James Fleming and Catherine Phelan. How he came to know the Sullivan family is a mystery, but Carrickbeg and Clogheen are within walking distance across the mountains. James and perhaps both Paul and William Sullivan were more than just sympathetic to the anti British Feneans but it was James who had to flee the country and make his way to North America.
James entered North America by way of Canada and worked there on the railroads, and by 1873 he eventually found his way to the town of Kingston in Ulster County NY. It's not clear if James and Mary had pledged themselves to each other before he left Ireland (he was 20 years old and she was merely 12). Mary came to America between June and October of 1873 and married James Fleming on October 26, 1873. James Fleming Jr was born the following August in Kingston NY the first of 11 children, and the only child not born in Rosendale.
Rosendale, NY 1875
By 1875 the family had moved to Rosendale NY where James found work at the James B. James Cement Company as a quarryman. The house pictured at the left actually belonged to the James B James Cement Company and was used to house several of the mine employees and their families. Across the road from the house was one of several of the James Company mines. The Fleming family lived in the house from 1883 until it was purchase by James Fleming in 1899. It remains in the family to this day.
Joseph Fleming one of the 11 children of James and Mary Fleming, wrote extensively about his childhood years on James Street, much of which was published in The Rosendale News under the title Do You Remember from 1938 through 1943. He became the Assistant Editor to that paper and some of his remembrances also appear in the booklet A Story of James Street indexed by Linda Tantillo which is available at the Rosendale Public Library. The story of this generation of Fleming's is a story unto itself and will be documented in later issues of POI
Picture below left; The house on James Street as it appeared in 1912. Notice the stairway to the second floor on either side. The stairs were built to provide access to second floor apartments for employees of the James Mine.
St Peter RC church on James Street Rosendale, NY
Saint Peter Church sits at the head of James Street below the old railroad station and bridge that crosses the Roundout River. The present edifice was built in 1873, a year prior to the time when James and Mary Fleming came to the region. An early description of the church and its surroundings appeared in the Catholic journal below.
The parish of St. Peter's has a somewhat peculiar history. Owing to the discovery of natural cement in the mountains, the territory underwent a rapid development. The displacement of a natural product by a superior article being put on the market caused a serious calamity to the neighborhood for numbers of families that emigrated. Rosendale was at first a mission of Roundout (Kingston), and the church built by Father Martin, its first pastor, now serves as a school. The present buildings are on a plateau overlooking the entire village, and stand as a monument to the memory of Father O'Flaherty the priest who planned and built the church and rectory, and Father Gleason who established the school and convent. The school is in charge of 4 Sisters of Charity and has about 120 pupils. Rosendale has two missions at Whiteport and High Falls, where Father Hickey built a church as well as the station at Rifton Glen. - The Catholic Church in America
New York, NY 1889 - 1894
Christopher Sullivan originally landed in the Port of Boston in 1885 but it is unclear just how long he stayed there. It is clear that by January of 1889 he was living at 788 Washington Street on the west side of Manhattan, NY as verified by his Declaration of Intent to become a citizen of the United States. The area today bears little resemblance to the gritty assemblage of warehouses bars and boarding houses of the late 1880's. At the time the tracks of the New York Central Railroad ran down the street and there were numerous collisions resulting in many fatalities. Because of this, Tenth Avenue became known as the "Avenue of Death". By the 1930's Robert Moses, in an attempt to reduce the public threat, decided to push for an alternative to the grade level tracks by elevating them above the street level. The building at 788 Washington was directly in the path of the new project, and it was demolished. The tracks were designed to run directly through the warehouses and factories, and many of the buildings that were occupied by companies like Swift Co. and Nabisco still stand today.
The original elevated structure ran from the rail yards at 34th Street down to St John's Park Terminal, the area near Spring Street. The new railroad however, never achieved the purpose to which it was designed and by the 1950's it fell into disuse. As part of an urban renewal plan in the early 1960's the tracks between Spring Street and Gansevoort Street were demolished. At the present site of what was 788 Washington Street stands the modern Condo pictured below left.
A little over two years later on March 11, 1891 Christopher Sullivan appeared before a Superior Court Judge and petitioned the court to become a citizen of the United States. On the Petition for Naturalization his address is listed as 158 Christopher Street another site where he would not remain for very long because that address was also destined for great changes. By the end of 1894 that address and many of the buildings around it had been demolished to make way for the The Customs Warehouse a storage for imports awaiting inspection by customs officers. Later the building was designated as a storage facility for the US Federal Archives and became known as The Public Archive Building "The Archives", as it is now known is an impressive building and it still stands at the foot of Christopher Street although it has not been used to store records since the 1980's when it was converted into condominiums. The picture to the lower right was taken in 2003, and clearly shows why this beautiful building has been granted landmark status.
Long Island City, NY 1894 - 1898
On September 5, 1894 Christopher James Sullivan and Catherine Marie O'Donnell were married in Sacred Heart Church Newton Center (below), Massachusetts and by that time it is clear from the marriage record that Christopher has now moved to Long Island City, NY. Long Island City, in Queens County (not yet a part of New York City) is a busy manufacturing and food distribution center along the East River Estuary which served the City of New York (Manhattan ) across the river.
One of those businesses relatively new to the the area was begun in 1883 by brothers Benjamin and Robert Moore, who immigrated to the United States from Ireland. The Benjamin Moore Company was one of the many paint retailers that occupied space just across the bridge in neighboring Brooklyn, but before long they began to distinguish themselves by providing quality products for the rapidly growing population of the City of New York. Although I have never been able to substantiate that Christopher was an employee, I have good reason to believe that he was. More on that later.
William Joseph Sullivan was born on June 18, 1895 in a small Long Island City apartment located at 68 7th Street (below left) just west of Vernon Boulevard. I had great difficulty finding where Bill and his sister Mary Agnes Sullivan were born until I finally got a break in 2003. While researching my Uncle Bill's draft registration card for World War 1, I noticed that it listed his place of birth as Long Island City. I already knew that he was born in 1895 and she in 1897, so from there it was easy to find their birth certificates in the Long Island City birth records. Mary Sullivan was born in the building just around the corner at number 119 Vernon Avenue (photo right).
The one thing that I always found consistent about tracking the whereabouts of the Sullivan family is that they always lived within close proximity to the neighborhood Catholic Church, in this case St Mary's Long Island City (below right). Why so important to find the local church? The Sullivan Family were practicing Catholics, and therefore all the children would be baptized according to the rites of the church. Since baptismal records always document who the godparents are it is a great opportunity to uncover the mix of family relationships heretofore unknown. In this case Catherine's sisters Mary and Margaret, and Mary's husband Patrick Mulcahy. The Mulcahy name will appears elsewhere in the family tree and can be found in Vital records.
Brooklyn, NY 1898 - 1902
Of all the places connected with this branch of the Sullivan Family, none plays a more prominent role than the Borough of Brooklyn (Kings County) New York. It is where the family grew and prospered, rose and fell. If they moved (and they did so frequently) it was, with one exception, within the neighborhoods of Park Slope and Sunset Park in Brooklyn. The exact date the family moved there is uncertain, but the first clear evidence is Arthur's birth in November of 1899. the residence is 185 42nd Street in the Sunset Park section of Brooklyn. Finding them was very difficult because oddly enough it seems that both Arthur (1899) and Joseph (1902) have no birth certificate on file at the Municipal Archives. As hard as I tried, I could not find a birth record in any of the 5 Boroughs even taking into the possibility of a clerical error. So another approach would be necessary if I were ever to be successful.
The only other method for locating the family would have to be the Brooklyn Directory list for the years 1897 through 1899 and that proved to be successful. The first listing for Christopher was for 1898, and he was remarkably easy to trace because there were only two or three Christopher Sullivans listed in the entire city. Once I had the address I looked for the closest RC Church and it happened to be directly across the street from their residence. As I stated earlier, never far from the church, in this case the beautiful Church of St Michael's. St. Michael's Church is a prominent fixture on the landscape of Third Avenue Brooklyn, almost directly in line with the Statue of Liberty across Upper New York Harbor. From the baptismal certificates I was able to verify the date of birth for Arthur T Sullivan and Joseph A Sullivan.
Sidestep to Belleville, New Jersey 1902 - 1905
As I wrote earlier, the family resided in the Brooklyn neighborhoods of Park Slope and Sunset Park with one exception, and that was a brief sidestep to Belleville, New Jersey between the the latter part of 1902 through 1905. It's not clear just why they moved to New Jersey, perhaps it was because Benjamin Moore had just opened a new paint manufacturing plant, or just to be closer to his brother Ed who was ailing (Ed's wife Margaret was also Catherine's sister). My father Edward Sullivan was born in the town of Belleville, Essex County New Jersey on March 6, 1904 and already there was a controversy. His Birth Certificate indicates that he was named Charles (after Christopher's brother in Quincy, Massachusetts) but at some point shortly after that, his parents changed their mind. He was baptised 14 days later in St Peter's RC Church in Belleville NJ and his Baptismal Certificate clearly shows that he was christened Edward Sullivan in honor of his Uncle Ed. I know that later this caused some problems for my father when he and my mother were planning their wedding in June of 1943 because he was required to get a sworn affidavit in order to get an amended certificate from the State of New Jersey.
Return to Brooklyn 1905 - 1912
Using the Brooklyn Directory for 1905 the Sullivans appear again in Brooklyn at 184 8th Street in Park Slope (left) joining the parish of St. Thomas Aquinas Church on Ninth Street and Third Ave in Park Slope Brooklyn (below left). The house itself was a relatively small building just off the corner of Third Avenue on a quiet tree lined street. The neighborhood of Park Slope must have been a desirable place for the family because of its proximity to Church, and also the schools which at the time were considered better than average. I have not been able to establish where Christopher worked at the time, but it must have been one of the many factories the predominated the Gowanus region of Brooklyn. By late 1906 Catherine and Christopher were expecting another child, and the small quarters would no longer be sufficient. The family moved for the final time to a new apartment building on the corner of Third Avenue and 16th Street in Park Slope pictured at the lower right.
The building at 586 3rd Avenue is a rather large building, unusual for the time in which it was built around the turn of the last century. The fact that it is still standing at all is a miracle in itself no thanks to Robert Moses again. On two separate occasions the property stood perilously close to destruction, first in the early 1940's when the Gowanus Expressway was constructed over the route of the just demolished 3rd Avenue elevated train, and again in the late 1950's when the
extension for the Prospect Expressway was built bisecting Prospect Park West past Pritchard Square and cutting off the area surrounding Greenwood Cemetery. Buildings on the east side of Third Avenue fronting the road were demolished in order to make room for the highway above as well as expanding Third Avenue below the elevated roadway.
It was at 586 3rd Avenue where Margaret Sullivan was born on February 5, 1907, and Paul Sullivan two years later on September 23, 1909 (Also note the obvious error listing the mother's maiden name as Ryan). From the admission records of St John's Home for boys I was able to determine that the children attended nearby PS 40 which was situated almost equally between 3rd and 4th Avenues on 15th Street. The building was constructed sometime in the mid 1880's and by the time the family had moved to that location the facility was hopelessly outdated. Yet somehow it survived until the early 1950's when it was demolished. and replaced with a multifamily dwelling. Life was good here but it was about to take a drastic turn.
In March 1910, at six months of age young Paul developed whooping cough which developed into Pneumonia and taking the life of the infant on April 7. He was buried in the family plot in Calvary Cemetery Middle Village, NY. The family health issues were however were just beginning. Catherine and Christopher were already ill, and the effects of tuberculosis were beginning to take a toll. By the Middle of 1911 Catherine took to her sick bed and became incapacitated, while Christopher struggled to work until he too was unable to continue. During this time the children were looked after by the Feis family and Martha Lehman, Arthur's Godmother.
Christopher Sullivan was committed to St. Peter's Hospital Brooklyn, NY on December 28, 1911 followed by Catherine 11 days later on the 8th day of January. While the end came quickly for Catherine on the following day, Christopher lingered for an additional 42 days before expiring on February 20, 1912. They were buried in Calvary Cemetery in Maspeth, NY, at the same site where their infant son was laid to rest less than two years earlier. The report from the Child Welfare Agency gives insight as to the timeline of events during that period of time. It appears on the forms for Arthur, Joe, and Ed when they were admitted to St. John's Home for Children.
From The Child Welfare Department:
Father is in St. Peter's Hospital. He has not been able to work since October 1911.Mother is also sick (consumptive) and is unable to take care of home or children. There are six children; one is working, earns $4.50 per week. In view of the fact that the family is destitute, and that the mother is not in condition to look after her family, four children were committed by this department and the two oldest will remain at home. There are no relatives able to assist.
St Peter's Hospital Church and School Cobble Hill Brooklyn, NY
The St. Peter's Complex between Warren and Congress Sreets in the Cobble Hill section of Brooklyn, NY. The building in the picture to the left was St. Peter's Hospital from 1889 through 1962 when it closed. Both Christopher and Catherine Sullivan died in this building within 42 days of each other in 1912. In 1964 the hospital was renovated and much of it's landmark facade was removed, much to the dismay of local preservationists. In that same year the former hospital building opened as a senior care facility.
In the picture below, also taken in 2004, the lettering above the main entrance to the old school is still clearly visible above the doorway. The facility was completed in late 2004 and much of the space is sold..
St. Peter's School closed in 1962 was sold in the early 1980's to a developer who wished to redevelop the property. The Cobble Hill Society pushed for landmark status for the buildings delaying any plans for for demolishing the school and the church. By 1984 a plan was filed with the city which proposed that the exterior of the property would be maintained in it's preexisting condition, while the interior would be gutted and converted to condominium apartments. The picture above left shows St. Peter's School (left), and the church (right). By the time this picture was taken in 2004, the steeple and all the stained glass windows had been removed. The steel and brick barrier in the foreground is the Brooklyn Queens Expressway which, when it was designed and built by Robert Moses effectively served to isolate the neighborhood of Red Hook from Cobble Hill causing its demise as a desirable working class neighborhood.
St John's Home For Boys Brooklyn, NY
Picture above: St John's Home for Boys as it appeared around the early 1900's and in the picture to the right in 2004. It is now public housing.
In 1868 under the care of the Sisters of St Joseph, St. John's Home opened on the site near Albany and Troy Avenues in Brooklyn, NY. My father and his two brothers Arthur and Joe were housed in the complex pictured above from 1912 until my father left under the care of his older brother Arthur in 1920. Although they lost their parents under tragic circumstances, they always spoke lovingly of the place that was their home during those years. It was probably the closest they ever came to a childhood.
By 1954 a new facility was opened in the Rockaway Beach area of Queens County NY and the complex in Brooklyn was closed for good. When the new living facilities were opened in 1970, my Uncle Joe attended a school reunion. Needless to say he was thrilled to see some of his old buddies again. Although the times have changed, St John's Home For Boys continues on it's mission to care for disadvantaged children, preparing them for their entrance into society.
Blackford Ave West New Brighton, Richmond County, NY (Staten Island)
I really do not have much information about Edward Sullivan, his very existence was a mystery to me until 2005. It was my Uncle Joe who had vague memories of him and as it turned out, he was right on. It appears Christopher Sullivan's younger brother Edward came to America in 1899 and settled on the west side of lower Manhattan as his brother did several years earlier. There is no way to prove that the 1900 Census image I found is his, but there is some circumstantial evidence that points to it being correct. Like his brother Christopher, the census lists his occupation as Miller (flour) and that her entered the US in 1899. He is also unmarried.
The methods I used for finding him have already been well documented on The Lost Child, The Family Newsletter 2 so there is no need to repeat the story however; the meager details collected from that search help to paint picture of this branch of the family. Edward Sullivan and Margaret O'Donnell were married sometime around 1900 although as yet, I have not been able to determine where. The Massachusetts town registers have all been searched and I have good reason to believe that they were married elsewhere. The records for the City of New York have been searched years ago, but I feel that another search is in good order.
The first address listed for the family, Blackford Avenue West New Brighton, Richmond County NY comes from the birth certificate of William Edward Sullivan born December 3, 1901. The only other address 383 Richmond Ave, also in West New Brighton, is lifted from Edward Sullivan's Death Certificate in 1906. Also taken from the death certificate is the place of burial, St Peter's Cemetery on Staten Island. Other things I learned about the early 1900's in Staten Island was that there was at least one large flour mill there and it is possible that Edward was an employee of that mill.
After his death in 1906, Margaret and her son William left New York for Barre, Massachusetts near the city of Worcester. The 1910 Census shows Margaret has remarried to George A. Graton and bore two sons, Burton and Robert. There is no further listing for her indicating she passed away sometime before 1920.
Last but certainly not least is the town of Quincy Massachusetts, a small textile and shipbuilding town just to the south of the city of Boston. Quincy is most famous as the home of President John Adams. Although the Adams farm is long since gone, the home has been preserved and is a national landmark. Charles Sullivan and Margaret Mulcahy immigrated to America on the SS Austrian on 28 September1886. They were married soon after at St John the Baptist Church in Quincy Massachusetts on 7 November 1886. The very first address that I have been able to uncover from the Quincy City Directory of 1888 lists them as living at 87 Water Street where William was born. and it appears they will remain there at least until the end of 1888. At the beginning of 1889 and prior to March of that year, they have moved to 38 Water Street which will become their primary residence for the next 11 years. Confirmation of that move is found in the birth register of Charles Sullivan which lists his address as 38 Water Street, in fact it is the only birth record for the three children that gives an address. It is at 38 Water Street that their children Charles and Julia will begin their lives. In fact as I will document, in the course of their marriage, Margaret and Charles will never move more than a mile from the place they first called home.
Occupation: Plasterer, Laborer, Mason
87 Water St 1888-1890 William born here November 16, 1887
38 Water St 1891-1901 Charles born here March 2 1889 Julia born here June 6,1890
96 Water St 1902-1914
44 Pearl Street 1915-1936